67 Christian Would You Rather Questions

Hey there! Ever found yourself in a fun conversation, maybe with friends or at a youth group, and someone pops out with a "Would You Rather?" question? Well, Christian Would You Rather Questions take that playful idea and give it a spiritual twist. They're a fantastic way to explore your faith, get to know others better, and even have some serious (or hilarious!) discussions about what matters most in life, all through the lens of Christianity.

What Are Christian Would You Rather Questions?

So, what exactly are these Christian Would You Rather Questions? Think of them as mini thought experiments. You're presented with two options, and both usually involve a scenario related to Christian beliefs, values, or practices. The goal isn't to find the "right" answer, but to see how you'd navigate different situations and what choices reflect your understanding of your faith. They're popular because they make talking about faith engaging and less intimidating. Instead of a lecture, it's a game! People use them for all sorts of reasons:

Icebreakers for new groups
Discussion starters for Bible studies
Fun activities at church events
Personal reflection on spiritual growth

The importance of these questions lies in their ability to encourage thoughtful engagement with faith in a lighthearted yet meaningful way. They can reveal what we prioritize, where our strengths might be, and even where we might need to grow in our understanding of God's Word. It’s a way to test your own spiritual compass without any real-world consequences, which can be incredibly helpful.

Here are some of the ways they work and why they're so effective:

They force you to consider trade-offs. Often, both choices have pros and cons, making you think about what you value more.
They can be customized. You can tailor them to specific Bible stories, teachings, or even current events.
They promote empathy. Hearing someone else's answer can help you understand their perspective and how they approach their faith journey.

It's all about sparking conversations and learning from each other!

Everyday Faith Scenarios

Would you rather always have to pray out loud, even when you’re alone, or never be able to pray out loud again?
Would you rather give up your favorite hobby for a year to serve others, or continue your hobby but only on Sundays after church?
Would you rather be known as someone who is incredibly wise but rarely speaks, or someone who speaks a lot but isn't always wise?
Would you rather have a personal Bible that is constantly being corrected by others, or have a Bible that is always perfectly accurate but you can never share it?
Would you rather be able to instantly speak every language in the world but forget how to read, or be able to read every book ever written but never speak another language?
Would you rather have your prayer requests answered immediately but with a twist you didn't expect, or have them answered slowly but exactly as you asked?
Would you rather always forgive someone instantly, even if they don't apologize, or only forgive after a sincere apology and a period of reflection?
Would you rather have your greatest talent be teaching others about faith, or have your greatest talent be living out your faith so inspiringly that people ask you about it?
Would you rather have to give away 10% of your income to charity every month, or spend 10 hours volunteering every month at a place of your choice?
Would you rather always be the one serving others, or always be the one being served by others?
Would you rather have to read the entire Bible aloud to your family every night for a year, or memorize one Psalm a week for a year and recite it?
Would you rather be able to perform miracles but keep it a secret, or be able to talk to angels but never share what they say?
Would you rather have a life free of major trials but with little spiritual growth, or a life full of challenges that lead to deep spiritual growth?
Would you rather be able to convince anyone of anything with your words, or be able to discern truth from falsehood instantly?
Would you rather have to wear a visible symbol of your faith at all times, or have to share your faith with one stranger every single day?
Would you rather be able to hear God's voice clearly during times of confusion, or be able to see God's plan unfolding perfectly in hindsight?
Would you rather be the most prayerful person in your church but struggle with doubt, or be someone who rarely prays but has unwavering faith?
Would you rather always have to lead the prayer at every gathering, or always have to be the one to quietly support the leader?
Would you rather have a strong sense of God's presence when you are struggling, or have a strong sense of God's presence when you are celebrating?
Would you rather be able to instantly understand complex theological concepts, or be able to explain them so simply that a child understands?

Biblical Dilemmas

Would you rather be in the crowd that shouted "Crucify him!" or be in the crowd that praised Jesus on Palm Sunday?
Would you rather have been one of the disciples who doubted Jesus after the resurrection, or one of the disciples who ran away during his arrest?
Would you rather have been Pharaoh's daughter who raised Moses, or Moses's mother who had to send him away?
Would you rather have been Jonah who ran from God, or Job who suffered immense loss?
Would you rather have been Mary, the mother of Jesus, facing immense scrutiny, or Martha, constantly worried about serving?
Would you rather have been one of the wise men who traveled a great distance, or the shepherds who were nearby when Jesus was born?
Would you rather have been Lot's wife who looked back, or Noah who diligently built the ark?
Would you rather have been Peter, who denied Jesus, or Judas, who betrayed him?
Would you rather have been Ananias and Sapphira who lied about their offering, or Barnabas who generously gave?
Would you rather have been Goliath challenging David, or David facing Goliath?
Would you rather have been John the Baptist, facing persecution for speaking truth, or King Herod, in power but morally compromised?
Would you rather have been Rahab, a prostitute who helped God's people, or a Roman soldier present at the crucifixion?
Would you rather have been the prodigal son who wasted his inheritance, or the elder son who was resentful?
Would you rather have been the woman at the well who encountered Jesus, or one of the Pharisees who questioned Jesus?
Would you rather have been Elijah calling down fire from heaven, or Elisha asking for a double portion of Elijah's spirit?
Would you rather have been Samson whose strength was his downfall, or King Saul who lost God's favor?
Would you rather have been the man healed by Jesus who was told to not tell anyone, or the man healed who couldn't help but tell everyone?
Would you rather have been Abraham asked to sacrifice Isaac, or Sarah, who had to wait so long for a child?
Would you rather have been the disciples who saw Jesus walk on water, or those who didn't believe?
Would you rather have been Paul, persecuted for his faith, or Silas, imprisoned with Paul?

Spiritual Gifts and Talents

Would you rather have the gift of prophecy but be constantly misunderstood, or the gift of service but never receive recognition?
Would you rather be able to heal the sick with a touch but suffer with them, or be able to comfort the grieving with words but feel their pain deeply?
Would you rather have the gift of teaching the Bible perfectly but never be able to apply it yourself, or be able to live out the Bible perfectly but struggle to explain it?
Would you rather have the gift of giving so generously that you always have enough, or the gift of discernment to always know where to give?
Would you rather have the gift of leadership to inspire others to follow God, or the gift of quiet prayer to intercede for the world?
Would you rather have the gift of wisdom to make perfect decisions, or the gift of faith to move mountains?
Would you rather have the gift of tongues but no one understands you, or the gift of interpretation but you only get snippets?
Would you rather have the gift of mercy to forgive everyone easily, or the gift of justice to uphold righteousness uncompromisingly?
Would you rather have the gift of faith to believe anything is possible, or the gift of knowledge to understand God's creation?
Would you rather have the gift of healing physical ailments but be unable to heal spiritual ones, or the gift of bringing spiritual healing but be unable to fix physical problems?
Would you rather have the gift of encouragement to lift everyone's spirits, or the gift of exhortation to challenge people towards righteousness?
Would you rather have the gift of discernment to see through deception, or the gift of peace to bring calm to chaos?
Would you rather have the gift of administration to organize ministries effectively, or the gift of hospitality to make everyone feel welcome?
Would you rather have the gift of miracles but be unable to explain them, or the gift of understanding to explain every miracle?
Would you rather have the gift of intercessory prayer that always gets answered, or the gift of evangelism that always leads to conversion?
Would you rather have the gift of music to bring people closer to God through song, or the gift of art to visually represent God's glory?
Would you rather have the gift of helps to assist those in need, or the gift of compassion to feel deeply for the suffering?
Would you rather have the gift of speaking truth with boldness but risk offending, or speak truth gently but risk being ignored?
Would you rather have the gift of building strong communities, or the gift of nurturing individual spiritual growth?
Would you rather have the gift of understanding the spiritual realm, or the gift of protecting people from spiritual attack?

Living a Christian Life

Would you rather be persecuted for your faith but have a clear conscience, or be popular but have to compromise your beliefs?
Would you rather live a life of quiet service that no one notices, or a life of bold evangelism that draws attention?
Would you rather have a deep, personal relationship with God but few friends, or have many friends but a superficial relationship with God?
Would you rather always do what is right but be misunderstood, or do what is popular but know it’s wrong?
Would you rather have to share your faith with people who reject you constantly, or have people easily accept your faith but you struggle to live it out?
Would you rather be a light in a dark world and face challenges, or live in a comfortable world with less spiritual impact?
Would you rather have your prayers answered with "yes" or "no," or with "wait"?
Would you rather have the freedom to express your faith openly but face opposition, or have to practice your faith privately but without conflict?
Would you rather be known for your love for God or your love for people?
Would you rather have your faith tested by doubt or by suffering?
Would you rather always be the one giving, or always be the one receiving support?
Would you rather have a life filled with opportunities to serve, or opportunities to lead?
Would you rather be able to see God's hand in every situation, or be able to feel God's presence in every moment?
Would you rather have to share your deepest struggles with a trusted mentor, or keep them hidden and try to overcome them alone?
Would you rather have a life that resembles the Sermon on the Mount, or a life that mirrors the teachings of Paul?
Would you rather be able to resist temptation perfectly but never feel the struggle, or be able to fight temptation and learn from your victories?
Would you rather have your faith grow through intense trials, or through peaceful, consistent spiritual disciplines?
Would you rather be known as a peacemaker, or a truth-teller who challenges injustice?
Would you rather have your greatest joy in helping others find salvation, or in deepening your own relationship with Christ?
Would you rather live a life where your actions always speak louder than your words, or where your words always clearly reflect your actions?

Humorous and Lighthearted Christian Questions

Would you rather have to sing every sentence you speak, or have to rhyme every sentence you speak?
Would you rather your halo be slightly crooked, or your wings be a bit too small?
Would you rather have to wear a perpetual smile, or have to constantly look surprised?
Would you rather have a choir of angels follow you around, singing loudly off-key, or have a single angel whisper bad jokes in your ear all day?
Would you rather have to give a sermon every time you order food at a restaurant, or have to baptize every stray animal you see?
Would you rather your confession be broadcast on national television, or your prayer requests be read out at every public event?
Would you rather have to talk like a pirate every Sunday at church, or wear a silly hat every day for a year?
Would you rather your Bible have sticky pages that constantly flip to random verses, or have footnotes that are all actually just riddles?
Would you rather have to do a little dance every time you say "Amen," or have to do a cartwheel every time you quote scripture?
Would you rather have to explain the Gospel using only interpretive dance, or have to explain it using only animal sounds?
Would you rather have your prayer answered with a chorus of "Hallelujah!" every time, or with a gentle "Well done, my child"?
Would you rather have to wear socks with sandals for the rest of your life, or have to eat only unleavened bread for a month?
Would you rather your guardian angel be a talking squirrel, or a grumpy badger?
Would you rather have to preach from a ladder that’s always slightly wobbly, or from a pulpit that randomly dispenses confetti?
Would you rather your worship songs always have extra, nonsensical verses, or have every hymn suddenly turn into a pop song?
Would you rather have to give a high-five to everyone you meet, or a gentle nod to everyone you meet?
Would you rather have your halo play elevator music whenever it’s on, or have your wings make a squeaking sound?
Would you rather have to bless every piece of food you eat in a dramatic, theatrical way, or have to confess your minor "sins" (like forgetting to water plants) every morning?
Would you rather your coffee always taste like communion wine, or your water always taste like the Jordan River?
Would you rather have to start every conversation with "Praise the Lord!" or end every conversation with a Bible verse?

See? Christian Would You Rather Questions can be a lot of fun and a great way to think about what your faith means to you. Whether you're using them to break the ice, spark deep conversations, or just have a good laugh, they’re a wonderful tool for exploring your spiritual journey. So next time you’re with friends or in a group, why not give them a try? You might be surprised by what you learn and how much fun you have!