73 Christmas Themed Would You Rather Questions

Get ready to jingle all the way into some fun! If you're looking for a way to spice up your holiday gatherings or just want to have a laugh with friends and family, then Christmas Themed Would You Rather Questions are the perfect solution. These playful dilemmas are designed to get everyone thinking, giggling, and maybe even a little stumped, all while celebrating the festive spirit of the season.

What Are Christmas Themed Would You Rather Questions and Why Are They So Fun?

Christmas Themed Would You Rather Questions are basically tricky little puzzles where you have to pick between two equally interesting or challenging holiday-related scenarios. Think of it like this: you're presented with two awesome (or sometimes, hilariously not-so-awesome) Christmas options, and you absolutely have to choose one. These questions are super popular because they’re a fantastic icebreaker, a way to spark conversation, and a surefire way to get everyone involved, no matter their age. They encourage people to imagine themselves in funny, heartwarming, or even slightly absurd situations, making them perfect for holiday parties, family game nights, or even just a cozy evening by the fire.

The beauty of these questions lies in their ability to be tailored to any group. You can make them:

Funny and silly
Thought-provoking and a little challenging
Nostalgic and heartwarming
Slightly controversial (in a good-natured way!)

The importance of these questions is that they create shared experiences and foster connection during a time meant for togetherness. They’re a low-pressure way to learn more about what people value, what makes them laugh, and how they see the world, all through the lens of everyone's favorite holiday.

Here are some of the ways Christmas Themed Would You Rather Questions can be used:

Party Games: Hand them out on slips of paper or ask them aloud to get guests mingling and laughing.
Family Fun: Use them around the dinner table or during gift-opening to add some extra cheer.
Road Trip Entertainment: Perfect for keeping everyone entertained on the way to visit family.
Social Media Engagement: Post them online to encourage interaction and holiday spirit.

Would You Rather... Classic Christmas Dilemmas

Be Rudolph with a permanently glowing red nose or have Santa's sack that only holds one gift at a time?
Have to sing Christmas carols badly all day every day for a week or have to wear an ugly Christmas sweater that itches uncontrollably for a month?
Only be able to eat gingerbread cookies for every meal for a week or only be able to drink eggnog for every drink for a week?
Receive a lump of coal every Christmas or have to re-gift every present you receive?
Have your Christmas tree be the only thing that lights up your house or have your house be decorated with only blinking, annoyingly loud Christmas lights?
Spend Christmas Eve helping Santa deliver presents or spend Christmas Day helping Mrs. Claus bake cookies for the elves?
Have to wear elf shoes all year round or have to wear Santa boots all year round?
Have a real reindeer as a pet or have a pet snowman that never melts?
Only be able to watch Christmas movies from the 1950s or only be able to watch Christmas movies from the 2010s?
Have to wear tinsel as your hair or have to wear baubles as your earrings?
Always wake up on Christmas morning to find your presents wrapped in plain brown paper or always wake up to find your presents wrapped in newspaper from 1985?
Have a Christmas tree that sheds glitter instead of needles or have a Christmas tree that hums carols constantly?
Have to communicate only through Christmas carols or have to communicate only through Christmas movie quotes?
Have to eat a whole candy cane in one go or have to eat a whole fruitcake in one go?
Be able to talk to gingerbread men or be able to talk to snowmen?
Have Santa's belly that jiggles like jelly or have Santa's laugh that sounds like a strangled goose?
Have to build a gingerbread house from scratch every year or have to frost and decorate a cake for every family gathering?
Always feel like you're covered in fake snow or always feel like you're wearing mittens indoors?
Have to give up hot chocolate for life or have to give up Christmas cookies for life?
Be permanently stuck at the North Pole or be permanently stuck in Santa's workshop?

Would You Rather... Santa's Shenanigans

Have Santa's sleigh break down on Christmas Eve and have to deliver presents by bicycle or have Santa's reindeer go on strike and have to deliver presents pulled by your family members?
Have to wear a velvet suit that is too tight or a velvet suit that is too itchy?
Have to answer every child's letter to Santa for a year or have to fix every broken toy in Santa's workshop for a year?
Have your beard turn into candy canes or have your hair turn into icicles?
Have to eat only Brussels sprouts for Christmas dinner or have to eat only plain oatmeal for Christmas dinner?
Be Santa Claus for one day and have to deal with all the chaos or be an elf for one day and have to work non-stop?
Have to wear bells on your shoes every day or have to wear a jingle bell collar?
Have Santa give you a lump of coal every year or have Santa give you a fruitcake that never goes bad?
Be able to fly but only in a straight line, like a missile, or be able to teleport, but only to the nearest chimney?
Have to sing a carol every time you enter a room or have to tell a Christmas joke every time you answer the phone?
Have to polish Santa's boots for eternity or have to sort Santa's mail for eternity?
Have your nose glow red like Rudolph's for one hour a day or have your ears grow to elf-like proportions for one hour a day?
Have to wear a permanent Santa hat or have to wear permanent reindeer antlers?
Be able to control the weather so it's always snowy at Christmas or be able to control the weather so it's always sunny at Christmas?
Have to eat all your presents before you can open them or have to re-wrap all your presents after opening them?
Have to give Santa a hug every time you see him or have to give Mrs. Claus a hug every time you see her?
Have to wear a suit made of gingerbread or a suit made of tinsel?
Be able to talk to Santa's reindeer or be able to talk to Santa's elves?
Have to wear oversized Santa shoes or have to wear oversized elf shoes?
Have your laughter sound like sleigh bells or have your sneezes sound like jingles?

Would You Rather... Festive Foods and Treats

Have to eat a whole gingerbread man made of pure salt or a whole candy cane made of pure mustard?
Have Christmas dinner consist only of mince pies or only of pudding?
Have to drink hot chocolate that is always too cold or always too spicy?
Have your Christmas tree made entirely of candy or entirely of cookies?
Have to eat candy canes that taste like garlic or gingerbread cookies that taste like onions?
Have to drink eggnog that tastes like pickles or mulled wine that tastes like toothpaste?
Have to bake a giant gingerbread house every year or frost and decorate a giant Christmas cake every year?
Have to eat a yule log that is actually made of wood or a Christmas pudding that is actually made of rocks?
Have to eat your Christmas dinner backwards, starting with dessert, or eat your Christmas dinner upside down, with the plate on the ceiling?
Have to only eat Christmas foods for a month or have to only eat healthy foods for a month?
Have to drink gravy as your main beverage or eat mashed potatoes as your main dessert?
Have to eat a roast turkey that is made of chocolate or a roast ham that is made of licorice?
Have to eat Christmas pudding for breakfast, lunch, and dinner for a week or eat Christmas pudding for every meal on Christmas Day?
Have to drink melted snowman water or drink reindeer sweat?
Have to eat a fruitcake that is as hard as a brick or a fruitcake that is as gooey as mud?
Have to make your own gingerbread dough from scratch using only a spoon or knead your own Christmas pudding dough using only your feet?
Have to drink mulled wine that is served in a boot or eggnog that is served in a Christmas stocking?
Have to eat a candy cane that is three feet long or a gingerbread man that is three feet tall?
Have to eat a gingerbread house that crumbles as soon as you touch it or a gingerbread house that is impossible to break?
Have to eat a gingerbread cookie that sings when you bite it or a candy cane that whispers secrets when you lick it?

Would You Rather... Festive Decorations and Traditions

Have to decorate your Christmas tree with only socks and underwear or only with kitchen utensils?
Have your Christmas tree be the only thing that lights up your house, or have your house be decorated with only blinking, annoyingly loud Christmas lights?
Have to wear a wreath as a hat or wear tinsel as a scarf all day?
Have to re-gift every present you receive or have to make every present you give?
Have to sing carols at the top of your lungs in public places or have to wear an outfit made entirely of Christmas wrapping paper?
Have your Christmas cards be written in invisible ink or have your Christmas cards be delivered by carrier pigeon?
Have to hang your stockings on the fireplace made of sandpaper or hang your stockings made of barbed wire?
Have to spend Christmas Eve building a snowman that is bigger than your house or a gingerbread house that is bigger than your house?
Have to wrap all your gifts in bubble wrap or wrap all your gifts in cling film?
Have to wear a Santa hat that plays loud music or wear elf shoes that squeak with every step?
Have to decorate your house with only red and white stripes or only with green and gold glitter?
Have to build a nativity scene using only potatoes or use only toilet paper rolls?
Have to hang your Christmas lights upside down or have your Christmas lights only work when you sing to them?
Have to have a Christmas tree that constantly sheds pine needles or a Christmas tree that constantly drops baubles?
Have to re-decorate your house with Christmas decorations every single day for a month or have to take them all down and put them back up every single day for a month?
Have to wear reindeer antlers that moo or a Santa hat that barks?
Have to tell a Christmas joke to every person you meet or have to sing a snippet of a carol to every person you meet?
Have to put your presents under the tree in order of height or in order of weight?
Have to have a Christmas tree that is alive and talks to you or a Christmas tree that is made of ice and melts every hour?
Have to wear socks made of holly or wear mittens made of mistletoe?

Would You Rather... Christmas Movie Mayhem

Be stuck in the movie "Home Alone" and have to outsmart the wet bandits or be stuck in the movie "Elf" and have to navigate the real world with Buddy?
Have to live in the movie "A Christmas Story" and deal with Ralphie's dad's leg lamp or live in the movie "It's a Wonderful Life" and have to save George Bailey?
Be the Grinch who steals Christmas and have to return it all or be Ebenezer Scrooge who has to change his ways overnight?
Have to play the role of the Snowman in "Frosty the Snowman" and know you'll melt or play the role of the Abominable Snowman in "Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer" and be feared?
Be the elf who drops Santa's sleigh keys or be the reindeer who accidentally eats Santa's list?
Have to watch "National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation" on repeat for 24 hours or watch "The Santa Clause" on repeat for 24 hours?
Be forced to wear an elf costume for every social event for a month or wear a Santa suit for every social event for a month?
Have to sing all your dialogue in "White Christmas" or have to dance all your dialogue in "Singin' in the Rain" (but it's Christmas-themed)?
Be the kid who wants the Red Ryder BB Gun in "A Christmas Story" or be the kid who gets a dog in "A Charlie Brown Christmas"?
Have to convince the entire town that Santa is real in a world that doesn't believe or have to convince yourself that Christmas is the best holiday ever in a world that hates it?
Be forced to live in a snow globe from a Christmas movie or live in a gingerbread house from a Christmas movie?
Have to be the reason Santa's sleigh gets stuck in the chimney in "Miracle on 34th Street" or be the reason the reindeer can't fly in "The Nightmare Before Christmas"?
Have to attend every Christmas party from "Bridget Jones's Diary" or every Christmas gathering from "Love Actually"?
Be the villain in a Christmas movie who wants to stop Christmas or the hero in a Christmas movie who has to save Christmas?
Have to live in a world where Christmas lasts for a year or a world where Christmas only happens once every ten years?
Have to be the parent who accidentally tells their kids Santa isn't real or the parent who buys a fake tree and pretends it's real?
Be forced to dance like the characters in "The Nutcracker" for an entire day or sing like the characters in "The Sound of Music" but with Christmas songs?
Have to live with the ghost of Christmas Past, Present, and Yet to Come at the same time or have to live with the entire cast of "The Muppet Christmas Carol"?
Be the character who gets coal in their stocking every year or the character who accidentally ruins Christmas for everyone?
Have to be the one who gets the amazing Christmas present everyone else wanted or the one who gets a terrible present that causes hilarious chaos?

Would You Rather... Winter Wonderland Woes

Have to live in a house made entirely of snow or a house made entirely of ice?
Have to wear a snowsuit made of itchy wool all year round or wear shorts and a t-shirt in a blizzard?
Have to only be able to travel by dog sled or by reindeer sled?
Have your Christmas tree be the only thing that lights up your house, or have your house be decorated with only blinking, annoyingly loud Christmas lights?
Have to build a snowman that is as tall as a house or a snow fort that can withstand an army?
Have to drink icicles as your main beverage or eat snowflakes as your main dessert?
Have to wear mittens made of ice or gloves made of fire (that don't burn you)?
Have to spend Christmas Day shoveling snow for a week or shoveling snow for a month?
Have to have snow that tastes like peppermint or snow that smells like pine needles?
Have to be a professional ice sculptor for a living or a professional snowman builder for a living?
Have to wear a hat made of snow or a scarf made of icicles?
Have to have your car stuck in the snow until February or have your car permanently covered in frost?
Have to live in a world where it snows candy canes or a world where it rains hot chocolate?
Have to eat your Christmas dinner on a frozen lake or have to eat your Christmas dinner on top of a very tall, snowy mountain?
Have to wear boots that are always filled with snow or shoes that are always filled with ice?
Have to have your Christmas lights be made of actual frost or have your Christmas tree be made of actual snowflakes?
Have to be able to talk to polar bears or be able to talk to penguins?
Have to spend your Christmas holidays in a blizzard with no power or a heatwave with no air conditioning?
Have to build a gingerbread house out of real gingerbread that’s melting or a snowman out of real snow that’s too warm?
Have to wear a coat made of ice or a hat made of snowflakes?

Would You Rather... Naughty or Nice Choices

Be on Santa's naughty list forever or be on Santa's nice list but have to do a chore for him every single day?
Have to steal one gift from under the tree or have to re-wrap all the gifts under the tree?
Be the kid who gets a lump of coal or the kid who gets a fruitcake that never goes bad?
Have to play a prank on Santa or have to play a prank on Mrs. Claus?
Be forced to be the Grinch for a day or be forced to be Santa's grumpy elf for a day?
Have to tell Santa a lie that he believes or tell him the truth that he doesn't want to hear?
Be on the naughty list and get a fake present or be on the nice list and get a real chore?
Have to eat a gingerbread cookie that whispers secrets about everyone or eat a candy cane that tells you lies?
Be the one who accidentally breaks a Christmas decoration or the one who accidentally eats a Christmas ornament?
Have to wear an outfit made of "naughty" items or an outfit made of "nice" items (that are still weird)?
Have to break one of Santa's rules on purpose or have to follow one of Santa's rules to an extreme?
Be the person who always gets the worst present or the person who always gives the worst present?
Have to tell Santa you've been naughty when you've been nice or tell Santa you've been nice when you've been naughty?
Be the reason for a Christmas mishap in a movie or be the reason for a Christmas mishap in real life?
Have to eat a cookie that makes you tell the truth or a cookie that makes you tell outrageous lies?
Be the character who tries to steal Christmas or the character who tries to save Christmas but messes it up?
Have to get a present from the naughty list or a task from the nice list?
Be the person who always complains about Christmas or the person who tries too hard to make it perfect?
Have to sneak cookies from Santa's plate or sneak a peek at your presents?
Be the one who accidentally ruins the Christmas spirit for everyone or the one who accidentally brings Christmas spirit to a place that hates it?

So there you have it! Christmas Themed Would You Rather Questions are a fantastic way to inject some extra fun and connection into your holiday celebrations. Whether you're looking for something silly, thought-provoking, or just a way to get people laughing, these questions are sure to deliver. Gather your loved ones, pick your favorites, and get ready for some memorable holiday moments!