73 Would You Rather Questions For Thanksgiving
Thanksgiving is a time for family, friends, and of course, delicious food! But sometimes, after the turkey is carved and the pie is passed, things can get a little quiet. That's where Would You Rather Questions For Thanksgiving come in! They're a fun and easy way to get everyone talking, laughing, and maybe even learning something new about each other.
What Are Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions and Why Are They a Hit?
So, what exactly are "Would You Rather Questions For Thanksgiving"? Simply put, they're a game where you present two equally tempting, tricky, or downright silly choices, and everyone has to pick one. It’s not about what’s right or wrong, but about the thought process behind your choice. Why are they so popular, especially around this time of year?
They break the ice and get conversations flowing.
They encourage creative thinking and humor.
They can reveal surprising perspectives and preferences.
The importance of these questions lies in their ability to foster connection and create memorable moments during a special holiday.
These questions are used in all sorts of ways. You can ask them around the dinner table, during a family game night, or even send them out via text to friends and family who can't be there in person. They’re great for breaking down awkward silences and getting even the shyest person to participate. Think of it as a lighthearted way to explore different viewpoints without any pressure.
Here are some categories of Would You Rather Questions For Thanksgiving to get your creative juices flowing:
Food-Related Dilemmas
1. Would you rather eat only mashed potatoes for the rest of your life or only cranberry sauce for the rest of your life?
2. Would you rather have Thanksgiving dinner with a side of burnt rolls every year or a side of undercooked turkey every year?
3. Would you rather have an unlimited supply of pumpkin pie but never be able to eat gravy again, or have an unlimited supply of gravy but never be able to eat pumpkin pie again?
4. Would you rather have your turkey be incredibly dry but perfectly seasoned, or incredibly juicy but completely bland?
5. Would you rather only be able to eat with your hands or only be able to eat with chopsticks at Thanksgiving dinner?
6. Would you rather have your stuffing be too soggy or too dry?
7. Would you rather have your green bean casserole be too mushy or too crunchy?
8. Would you rather have to make all the Thanksgiving desserts yourself from scratch, or clean all the Thanksgiving dishes by hand for a week?
9. Would you rather have your sweet potatoes be too sweet or not sweet enough?
10. Would you rather only be able to eat Thanksgiving dinner at 6 AM or 10 PM?
11. Would you rather have a Thanksgiving meal where all the food is lukewarm or a meal where everything is super spicy?
12. Would you rather have to eat turkey with your eyes closed or eat pie with a fork the size of a toothpick?
13. Would you rather have to make your own butter from scratch for all your Thanksgiving meals or churn your own ice cream?
14. Would you rather have your Thanksgiving gravy taste like maple syrup or taste like soy sauce?
15. Would you rather have your mashed potatoes be made with water instead of milk or have them be lumpy?
16. Would you rather have to eat your Thanksgiving dinner in complete silence or with someone singing loudly the entire time?
17. Would you rather have to eat a whole raw onion before your Thanksgiving meal or eat a whole raw potato?
18. Would you rather have your Thanksgiving turkey taste like chicken or have your Thanksgiving stuffing taste like sawdust?
19. Would you rather have to eat Thanksgiving dinner on the floor or standing up?
20. Would you rather have to bake all the pies with an oven that's too hot or an oven that's too cold?
Family & Friend Fun
1. Would you rather have to tell a really embarrassing story about yourself every Thanksgiving or have to sing a song about the meal?
2. Would you rather have your entire family wear matching, goofy Thanksgiving sweaters for life or have to watch a holiday movie marathon with relatives you barely know?
3. Would you rather have to play board games that last for days with your family or have to listen to your aunt tell the same story three times?
4. Would you rather have to bring a unique, complicated dish to Thanksgiving every year or have to be the designated photographer for all the family events?
5. Would you rather have your family start a dance party right in the middle of dinner or have everyone at the table start telling jokes simultaneously?
6. Would you rather have to explain a complicated topic to a young child during Thanksgiving or have to explain a simple topic to a confused grandparent?
7. Would you rather have your family decide to go on a surprise camping trip for Thanksgiving every year or have them insist on a formal, black-tie event?
8. Would you rather have to do charades about Thanksgiving traditions or have to do Pictionary with Thanksgiving foods?
9. Would you rather have to give a toast thanking everyone for the meal or have to write thank-you notes to each person there?
10. Would you rather have to do karaoke with your family during Thanksgiving or have to participate in a family talent show?
11. Would you rather have your relatives arrive three hours early every year or have them arrive three hours late?
12. Would you rather have to help your grandma with her knitting project for the entire Thanksgiving weekend or help your uncle with his elaborate train set?
13. Would you rather have to re-enact a historical Thanksgiving event with your family or have to create a modern Thanksgiving play?
14. Would you rather have to share your bed with a distant cousin you haven't seen in years or sleep on an air mattress in the living room?
15. Would you rather have to answer a "would you rather" question from every person at the table or have to tell a funny Thanksgiving memory?
16. Would you rather have your family play a prank on you every Thanksgiving or have to prank someone else?
17. Would you rather have to organize a scavenger hunt for the kids or organize a trivia game for the adults?
18. Would you rather have to help set up for Thanksgiving dinner for two hours or help clean up for three hours?
19. Would you rather have to sing a holiday song in a fake accent or tell a riddle that no one can guess?
20. Would you rather have your family invite a stranger to Thanksgiving dinner every year or have to attend a potluck with only people you've never met?
The Great Outdoors Vs. Cozy Indoors
1. Would you rather spend Thanksgiving Day hiking through a snowy forest or huddled by a crackling fireplace?
2. Would you rather have a Thanksgiving picnic in a park with a chance of rain or a Thanksgiving feast in a drafty, old house?
3. Would you rather go stargazing on Thanksgiving night or watch a Thanksgiving movie marathon with a huge pile of blankets?
4. Would you rather help your family build a snowman on Thanksgiving or help decorate the house with festive garlands?
5. Would you rather have a Thanksgiving bonfire with s'mores or a Thanksgiving cookie decorating party?
6. Would you rather go ice skating on Thanksgiving day or go apple picking?
7. Would you rather have a Thanksgiving feast on a boat or in a treehouse?
8. Would you rather go sledding on Thanksgiving or have a snowball fight?
9. Would you rather camp out in your backyard on Thanksgiving night or sleep in a fancy hotel?
10. Would you rather go on a hayride on Thanksgiving or attend a Thanksgiving craft fair?
11. Would you rather have your Thanksgiving dinner outdoors with all the elements or indoors with a really bad Wi-Fi signal?
12. Would you rather go on a nature walk on Thanksgiving or visit a local museum?
13. Would you rather have a Thanksgiving bonfire that's a little too smoky or a Thanksgiving indoor party that's a little too crowded?
14. Would you rather go fishing on Thanksgiving or visit a local farm?
15. Would you rather have a Thanksgiving picnic where you have to cook over a campfire or a Thanksgiving feast where the electricity keeps going out?
16. Would you rather explore a cave on Thanksgiving or visit an old, historical landmark?
17. Would you rather have a Thanksgiving scavenger hunt in the woods or in your house?
18. Would you rather go horseback riding on Thanksgiving or take a scenic train ride?
19. Would you rather have a Thanksgiving celebration on a beach or on a mountain?
20. Would you rather build a fort in the living room on Thanksgiving or go on an adventure in the backyard?
Hypothetical & Silly Scenarios
1. Would you rather have to communicate only through singing on Thanksgiving or only through interpretive dance?
2. Would you rather have your Thanksgiving turkey be able to talk but only complain, or have your Thanksgiving pie be able to sing but only off-key?
3. Would you rather have to wear a Pilgrim hat and shoes all day on Thanksgiving or a turkey costume?
4. Would you rather have to give thanks for every single thing that happens that day, even bad things, or only be allowed to say one thing you're thankful for?
5. Would you rather have your Thanksgiving feast be served by squirrels or have to eat your meal with your feet?
6. Would you rather have to invent a new Thanksgiving tradition that everyone has to follow or have to break an old, cherished tradition?
7. Would you rather have to fight a giant marshmallow or a swarm of tiny cranberries?
8. Would you rather have your Thanksgiving dinner interrupted by a parade of talking turkeys or a parade of singing pilgrims?
9. Would you rather have to carve the turkey with a butter knife or eat your pie with a shovel?
10. Would you rather have to wear socks on your hands and gloves on your feet all day on Thanksgiving or wear a napkin as a hat?
11. Would you rather have your Thanksgiving guests be all fictional characters or all historical figures?
12. Would you rather have to say "gobble gobble" after every sentence on Thanksgiving or wear a sign that says "I love turkey"?
13. Would you rather have your Thanksgiving meal be served on paper plates that are invisible or on plates made of solid gold?
14. Would you rather have to thank a different inanimate object every hour on the hour or have to make a funny face every time someone says "thankful"?
15. Would you rather have to wear a giant turkey hat for the rest of your life or have to quack like a duck every time you laugh?
16. Would you rather have your Thanksgiving gravy be made of chocolate or have your Thanksgiving pie be made of broccoli?
17. Would you rather have to narrate your entire Thanksgiving meal like a nature documentary or sing your grace before eating?
18. Would you rather have to give a presentation on the history of corn or the evolution of forks?
19. Would you rather have to wear a giant fork as a tiara or a giant spoon as a crown?
20. Would you rather have your Thanksgiving be attended by aliens who are fascinated by mashed potatoes or by robots who are trying to understand stuffing?
Future Thanksgiving & Past Traditions
1. Would you rather have future Thanksgivings be completely virtual with everyone on screen or have them all be in tiny, crowded spaces?
2. Would you rather have to relive your worst Thanksgiving memory every year or never be able to remember any of your Thanksgivings?
3. Would you rather have Thanksgiving traditions from the future, like teleporting food, or have to recreate every single tradition from the very first Thanksgiving?
4. Would you rather have Thanksgiving meals that are made by AI chefs or be forced to forage for your own food like early settlers?
5. Would you rather have your Thanksgiving meal be served in zero gravity or underwater?
6. Would you rather have to wear historically accurate clothing from the 17th century for every Thanksgiving or futuristic outfits from the 23rd century?
7. Would you rather have Thanksgiving be celebrated on a different planet every year or in a different historical era?
8. Would you rather have your Thanksgiving dinner be a competition where only the best eaters get dessert or a cooperative meal where everyone has to contribute equally?
9. Would you rather have Thanksgiving be a quiet, intimate affair with only your closest family or a massive, public celebration with strangers?
10. Would you rather have to invent a completely new Thanksgiving dish that everyone has to try or perfect a classic dish to an impossible standard?
11. Would you rather have Thanksgiving be celebrated with talking animals or with holographic historical figures?
12. Would you rather have to wear a VR headset that simulates a perfect Thanksgiving every year or experience a real but slightly imperfect Thanksgiving?
13. Would you rather have Thanksgiving be a silent retreat where no one speaks all day or a loud, boisterous festival with constant music?
14. Would you rather have to write a poem about your Thanksgiving every year or create a sculpture?
15. Would you rather have Thanksgiving meals that are always the same, perfect meal or meals that are always surprising and different?
16. Would you rather have to only eat food from your own childhood for Thanksgiving or food from a country you've never visited?
17. Would you rather have your Thanksgiving celebrated with a historical reenactment or a futuristic light show?
18. Would you rather have to participate in a Thanksgiving talent show that's judged by ghosts or a Thanksgiving storytelling contest judged by aliens?
19. Would you rather have Thanksgiving be a day of complete solitude and reflection or a day of intense social interaction?
20. Would you rather have to bring a dish that you've never made before to Thanksgiving every year or a dish that you've made perfectly a hundred times?
Thanksgiving "What If" Scenarios
1. What if you could have any celebrity, living or dead, join your Thanksgiving dinner? Who would it be and why?
2. What if your Thanksgiving turkey suddenly came to life and could grant you three wishes? What would you wish for?
3. What if you could travel back in time to experience Thanksgiving in any historical period? Which period would you choose?
4. What if you discovered that your favorite Thanksgiving dessert secretly contained a magical ingredient? What would the ingredient be and what would it do?
5. What if you could invent a brand new Thanksgiving tradition that everyone had to adopt? What would it be?
6. What if you were tasked with creating the ultimate Thanksgiving soundtrack? What songs would be on it?
7. What if you could swap lives with one of your Thanksgiving guests for the day? Who would you swap with and why?
8. What if your Thanksgiving decorations could talk? What would they say about your family?
9. What if you had to describe Thanksgiving to someone who had never heard of it using only three words? What would those words be?
10. What if your Thanksgiving feast was attended by mythical creatures? Which creatures would be there and what would they eat?
11. What if you could make any Thanksgiving food perfectly every single time, no matter what? Which food would you choose to master?
12. What if your Thanksgiving table was magically transformed into a boat sailing down a river? Where would you be going?
13. What if you had to give a TED Talk about your most memorable Thanksgiving? What would be the topic?
14. What if your Thanksgiving pie could tell the future? What would it predict for you?
15. What if you had to create a Thanksgiving-themed superhero? What would their powers be?
16. What if your Thanksgiving guests could only communicate through emojis? How would you manage dinner conversation?
17. What if you could have a Thanksgiving meal on any mode of transportation? Where would you eat?
18. What if your Thanksgiving turkey had a secret identity? What would it be?
19. What if you had to write a Thanksgiving jingle for a new product? What would the product be and what would the jingle say?
20. What if your Thanksgiving dinner was interrupted by a visit from Santa Claus? What would he be doing there?
So, there you have it! A whole bunch of Would You Rather Questions For Thanksgiving to get your holiday conversations buzzing. These aren't just silly questions; they're a playful way to connect, share laughs, and make your Thanksgiving celebration even more special. Happy questioning, and happy Thanksgiving!
