73 Would You Rather Questions For New Moms

73 Would You Rather Questions For New Moms
73 Would You Rather Questions For New Moms
Becoming a new mom is a whirlwind of emotions, exhaustion, and endless learning curves. In the midst of the beautiful chaos, sometimes a little lighthearted fun and connection can be exactly what's needed. That's where Would You Rather Questions For New Moms come in. These playful prompts offer a way to tap into the shared experiences of motherhood, sparking conversations, laughter, and a sense of solidarity.

What Are "Would You Rather Questions For New Moms" and Why Are They So Popular?

"Would You Rather Questions For New Moms" are a fun game where you're presented with two equally challenging, hilarious, or thought-provoking scenarios, and you have to choose which one you'd rather experience. They're not meant to be serious or judge anyone's parenting style. Instead, they're designed to be a relatable way for moms to connect over the unique joys and struggles of their new journey. These questions have become super popular because motherhood can sometimes feel isolating. When you're up at 3 AM with a crying baby, it's easy to feel like you're the only one going through it. Would You Rather Questions For New Moms create a space for moms to realize they're not alone. They can be used in various ways:
  • As icebreakers in new mom groups
  • To liven up a virtual hangout with other moms
  • As a fun way to pass the time during long feeding sessions
  • To simply have a good laugh and de-stress
The importance of these questions lies in their ability to foster connection and provide a sense of shared experience, reminding new moms that they are part of a supportive community.

Napping Dilemmas: The Sleep Deprivation Edition

1. Would you rather get 4 hours of uninterrupted sleep every night, or 8 hours of sleep with constant interruptions every 30 minutes? 2. Would you rather have your baby sleep through the night but wake up crying every hour during the day, or wake up crying every hour at night but sleep peacefully during the day? 3. Would you rather have your baby finally fall asleep the second you put them down, only to wake up the moment you sit down, or have them only fall asleep while you're actively rocking them? 4. Would you rather have a magical button that instantly makes your baby sleep for 2 hours, but it can only be used once a day, or a button that gives you a 30-minute energy boost whenever you need it, but it makes you feel jittery afterwards? 5. Would you rather only be able to sleep in a brightly lit room with loud noises, or only be able to sleep while wearing a full astronaut suit? 6. Would you rather sleep on a cloud that's a little too hard, or a beanbag chair that's a little too soft? 7. Would you rather have your baby wake up for a feeding exactly when your alarm is supposed to go off, or wake up 15 minutes before your alarm? 8. Would you rather have your baby wake up every 2 hours to nurse, or wake up every 2 hours to have their diaper changed? 9. Would you rather be able to teleport to your bed for a 15-minute nap whenever you want, but you can only go to your own bed, or be able to take a nap anywhere, but it only lasts for 5 minutes? 10. Would you rather have your baby wake up crying for a snack every 15 minutes, or wake up crying for a cuddle every 15 minutes? 11. Would you rather have a partner who snores like a freight train but never wakes the baby, or a partner who is completely silent but always accidentally wakes the baby? 12. Would you rather have a personal chef who only cooks breakfast foods, or a personal masseuse who only gives foot rubs? 13. Would you rather your baby be a super early riser but go down for naps easily, or sleep in late but fight every single nap? 14. Would you rather have the ability to instantly clean the house, but you can't sit down for an hour afterwards, or the ability to instantly get an hour of sleep, but the house becomes a disaster zone? 15. Would you rather have your baby wake up every time you try to sneak out of the room, or wake up every time you whisper? 16. Would you rather get a full night's sleep but have to sing a lullaby to your baby for 10 minutes every time they stir, or get 4 hours of sleep and have them magically quiet down on their own? 17. Would you rather have a baby who only sleeps when you're holding them, or a baby who only sleeps in a bouncy seat that rocks constantly? 18. Would you rather be able to dream about sleeping in a luxurious hotel, or actually get a solid 6 hours of sleep in your own bed? 19. Would you rather your baby wake up every 3 hours to feed, or wake up every 3 hours for a diaper change? 20. Would you rather have a noise machine that plays a perfect lullaby but sometimes randomly blasts rock music, or a white noise machine that's always consistent but sounds like a broken fan?

Feeding Frenzy: The Breastfeeding vs. Bottle Battle

1. Would you rather have your baby exclusively breastfeed and refuse all bottles, or exclusively bottle-feed and refuse to breastfeed? 2. Would you rather have to pump for 45 minutes every 3 hours, or have your baby nurse every 30 minutes for an hour at a time? 3. Would you rather have unlimited access to a lactation consultant who can magically solve any latching issue, but they live on another continent, or have your partner be an expert at making bottles and soothing, but they can only do it on weekends? 4. Would you rather have your baby take to breastfeeding immediately but have a very strong preference for one breast, or have a perfect alternating feeding schedule but struggle with latching sometimes? 5. Would you rather have your baby happily drink a bottle from anyone, but they only drink formula, or be exclusively breastfed but refuse any bottle from anyone but you? 6. Would you rather have your baby projectile vomit after every single feeding, or have your baby spit up a little bit after every single feeding? 7. Would you rather have to hand express milk for every feeding, or have a loud and leaky breast pump that scares the cat? 8. Would you rather have a baby who eats like a bird, taking tiny sips every hour, or a baby who guzzles milk like a champ but then needs a massive burp that shakes the room? 9. Would you rather have your partner be an expert at soothing the baby after a feeding, but they always smell like baby food, or be an expert at preparing bottles, but they always make a mess? 10. Would you rather have your baby accept all pacifiers except the one you actually like, or accept all burp cloths except the ones that are absorbent? 11. Would you rather have your baby have a perfect latch for breastfeeding but emit a faint squeak with every suckle, or have a perfect bottle-feeding technique but their gurgles are incredibly loud? 12. Would you rather have a freezer full of perfectly portioned breast milk that mysteriously disappears overnight, or a fridge full of formula that somehow always runs out at the worst possible moment? 13. Would you rather have your baby only breastfeed while you're standing up and swaying, or only breastfeed while you're lying down and can't move? 14. Would you rather have your baby be a champion eater, but their burps sound like a foghorn, or a dainty eater, but their sighs of contentment are piercingly high-pitched? 15. Would you rather have your partner be able to feed the baby a bottle in under 30 seconds, but they sing opera the whole time, or take 5 minutes to feed, but they tell you the most boring story? 16. Would you rather have a baby who exclusively breastfeeds on demand, meaning any time, anywhere, or a baby who needs a perfectly timed bottle every 3 hours sharp? 17. Would you rather have your baby only breastfeed when you're watching a dramatic movie, or only breastfeed when you're trying to have an important phone call? 18. Would you rather have your baby have a superhero cape that makes them a faster eater, but it also makes them super clingy, or a magic bib that catches all spit-up, but it also makes them smell faintly of lavender? 19. Would you rather have unlimited access to a personal chef who only makes baby food, or a personal assistant who can perfectly warm bottles and make sure they're the right temperature? 20. Would you rather have your baby breastfeed with a smile and a giggle, but their hands are constantly in your hair, or breastfeed with a serious expression, but their hands are perfectly still?

Diaper Disasters: The Messy Business

1. Would you rather have your baby consistently poop during every diaper change, or have your baby consistently pee the moment you take off their diaper? 2. Would you rather have a baby who only poops in the car seat, or a baby who only poops in the bathtub? 3. Would you rather have a diaper blow-out that goes up your baby's back and onto your shirt, or a diaper blow-out that goes down their legs and onto your shoes? 4. Would you rather have your baby scream bloody murder during every diaper change, or have your baby try to grab and eat the dirty diaper? 5. Would you rather have a diaper that has a faint smell of rotten eggs, or a diaper that has a bright yellow stain that won't come out? 6. Would you rather have your baby's poop be the consistency of water, or the consistency of sticky tar? 7. Would you rather have to use 10 baby wipes for every diaper change, or have your baby kick and squirm so much you can barely get the diaper on? 8. Would you rather have your baby have a diaper rash that looks like a constellation, or a diaper rash that smells like a gym locker? 9. Would you rather have a partner who is an expert at changing diapers but is incredibly clumsy, or a partner who is very gentle but takes forever? 10. Would you rather have a diaper bag that is perpetually overflowing with wet wipes, or a diaper bag that mysteriously empties itself of diapers? 11. Would you rather have your baby's poop be bright green and chunky, or bright orange and watery? 12. Would you rather have to change your baby's diaper in a public restroom with no changing table, or change it in your car with the doors open? 13. Would you rather have a diaper that leaks urine, or a diaper that leaks poop? 14. Would you rather have your baby's diaper smell like an amusement park after a hot day, or your baby's diaper smell like a science experiment gone wrong? 15. Would you rather have a baby who cries every time their diaper is dirty, or a baby who silently suffers until it's unbearable? 16. Would you rather have to use a diaper genie that is constantly full, or a diaper pail that never seals properly? 17. Would you rather have your baby's diaper situation be a constant surprise, with no way of knowing what's coming, or a constant predictable mess? 18. Would you rather have a baby who only poops during the most inconvenient times, like during a wedding or a job interview, or a baby who only pees when you've just put on a clean outfit? 19. Would you rather have a diaper rash that looks like a red map of the world, or a diaper rash that makes your baby wince with every touch? 20. Would you rather have a baby who leaves a trail of small messes wherever they go, or a baby who leaves one massive, epic mess in one spot?

Gear Galore: The Baby Stuff Struggle

1. Would you rather have a stroller that is incredibly lightweight and easy to maneuver but takes 10 minutes to fold, or a stroller that is a tank to push but folds in one second? 2. Would you rather have a baby carrier that is super comfortable for you but uncomfortable for the baby, or comfortable for the baby but gives you a backache? 3. Would you rather have a bouncer that plays annoying music constantly, or a swing that only swings in one direction? 4. Would you rather have a bottle warmer that takes 30 minutes to heat a bottle, or a formula dispenser that dispenses the wrong amount every third time? 5. Would you rather have a playard that is incredibly easy to set up but takes up your entire living room, or a playard that is difficult to set up but very compact? 6. Would you rather have a high chair that is easy to clean but has sharp edges, or a high chair that is soft and rounded but impossible to get clean? 7. Would you rather have a baby monitor that has perfect video quality but no sound, or perfect sound but blurry video? 8. Would you rather have a changing pad that is super soft but always leaks, or a changing pad that is waterproof but feels like a piece of cardboard? 9. Would you rather have a baby bathtub that is perfectly shaped for the baby but hard to get them in and out of, or easy to get them in and out of but they slide around constantly? 10. Would you rather have a baby swing that rocks your baby to sleep in 5 minutes but makes a loud grinding noise, or a baby swing that is silent but takes an hour to get them drowsy? 11. Would you rather have a car seat that is incredibly safe but a nightmare to install, or easy to install but feels a little flimsy? 12. Would you rather have a sterilizer that works perfectly but smells like burnt plastic, or a sterilizer that is quiet but sometimes doesn't fully sterilize? 13. Would you rather have a baby food maker that makes perfect purees but takes ages to clean, or a baby food maker that is quick to clean but often leaves chunky bits? 14. Would you rather have a portable crib that folds up small but is wobbly, or a portable crib that is sturdy but very heavy? 15. Would you rather have a baby gate that is easy to open but your baby can somehow always escape, or a baby gate that is incredibly secure but you struggle to open it? 16. Would you rather have a nursing pillow that is perfectly comfortable but always slides around, or a nursing pillow that stays in place but is lumpy? 17. Would you rather have a baby monitor that has a talking feature, but it always sounds like a robot, or a baby monitor that only shows you static? 18. Would you rather have a diaper pail that seals perfectly but you have to use special bags, or a diaper pail that uses regular trash bags but sometimes lets the smell escape? 19. Would you rather have a travel system that is incredibly convenient but weighs as much as a small child, or a travel system that is lightweight but very bulky? 20. Would you rather have a toy that your baby absolutely loves but is incredibly noisy and annoying to you, or a toy that is quiet and calming for you but your baby ignores it?

Parenting Philosophies: The Gentle vs. The Firm

1. Would you rather have a baby who cries every time you put them down, or a baby who cries every time you pick them up? 2. Would you rather have a baby who is so independent they never need you, or a baby who is so clingy they never let you out of their sight? 3. Would you rather have a toddler who throws tantrums over everything, or a toddler who has selective hearing and only listens when they want to? 4. Would you rather have a child who is a picky eater and will only eat one bland meal, or a child who will try anything but then projectile vomit it back up? 5. Would you rather have a baby who needs constant reassurance and cuddles, or a baby who is happy to entertain themselves for hours? 6. Would you rather have a child who is extremely curious and asks a million questions, or a child who is very quiet and observant? 7. Would you rather have a baby who is easily soothed by singing, but you have to sing off-key constantly, or a baby who is soothed by rocking, but they only fall asleep when you're doing a complex dance? 8. Would you rather have a child who is incredibly literal and takes everything you say at face value, or a child who is constantly testing boundaries and pushing limits? 9. Would you rather have a baby who needs a strict routine and gets upset when it's disrupted, or a baby who is very go-with-the-flow and doesn't seem to notice routines? 10. Would you rather have a child who is incredibly empathetic and feels the pain of others deeply, or a child who is very logical and problem-solves everything? 11. Would you rather have a baby who smiles at everyone they meet, or a baby who gives you the most precious smiles only when you're alone with them? 12. Would you rather have a child who is incredibly bossy and likes to tell everyone what to do, or a child who is very passive and goes along with everything? 13. Would you rather have a baby who is an early talker and says your name perfectly by 6 months, or a baby who is a late talker but then communicates through sophisticated sign language? 14. Would you rather have a child who is always asking "why?" to the point of exasperation, or a child who is always trying to "help" but makes more of a mess? 15. Would you rather have a baby who is a thrill-seeker and loves to climb everything, or a baby who is cautious and prefers to observe? 16. Would you rather have a child who communicates their needs clearly but loudly, or a child who hints at their needs but you have to guess? 17. Would you rather have a baby who wakes up happy and ready to play, or a baby who wakes up grumpy and needs a full hour to warm up? 18. Would you rather have a child who is incredibly dramatic and exaggerates everything, or a child who is very stoic and hides their emotions? 19. Would you rather have a baby who loves to be tickled and giggles uncontrollably, or a baby who prefers quiet cuddles? 20. Would you rather have a child who always wants to do the opposite of what you suggest, or a child who always agrees with you but then does their own thing anyway?

Milestone Mania: The "Is It Normal?" Edition

1. Would you rather have your baby crawl at 4 months but not walk until 2 years, or walk at 9 months but not crawl until 18 months? 2. Would you rather have your baby talk in full sentences by 1 year old but have terrible motor skills, or have amazing motor skills but be a late talker? 3. Would you rather have your baby sleep through the night from birth but never be a cuddly baby, or be a super cuddly baby but wake up every hour for the first year? 4. Would you rather have your baby start solids at 2 months old but be a picky eater their whole life, or wait until 6 months for solids and be an adventurous eater? 5. Would you rather have your baby be potty trained by 18 months but have intense separation anxiety, or be potty trained at 3 years old but be super independent? 6. Would you rather have your baby learn to feed themselves perfectly from the start but make a huge mess, or eat neatly from a spoon but take forever? 7. Would you rather have your baby wave goodbye enthusiastically at 5 months but not understand the concept of "no," or understand "no" perfectly at 5 months but never wave? 8. Would you rather have your baby be a super social butterfly from birth, or a shy observer who takes time to warm up? 9. Would you rather have your baby walk holding onto furniture at 6 months but be afraid of their own shadow, or be fearless and walk independently at 15 months? 10. Would you rather have your baby be able to stack blocks into a tower at 7 months but struggle with eye contact, or have perfect eye contact but only knock towers over? 11. Would you rather have your baby be an early reader, recognizing letters and sounds, but have difficulty with fine motor skills, or have excellent fine motor skills but be a late reader? 12. Would you rather have your baby learn to use a spoon perfectly at 9 months but only eat pureed food, or learn to use a fork at 15 months and eat finger foods? 13. Would you rather have your baby be incredibly independent and happy to play alone for extended periods, or be very interactive and need constant attention? 14. Would you rather have your baby master blowing raspberries at 3 months but have no interest in facial expressions, or have expressive faces but never learn to blow raspberries? 15. Would you rather have your baby be an early climber and explore everything, but be very accident-prone, or be a cautious crawler and rarely get hurt? 16. Would you rather have your baby learn to share toys naturally at 10 months but not understand taking turns, or understand taking turns at 18 months but struggle with sharing? 17. Would you rather have your baby be an early bloomer in terms of physical milestones but take longer to develop socially, or develop socially early but lag behind in physical milestones? 18. Would you rather have your baby be incredibly vocal and babble constantly, or be a quiet baby who communicates through gestures? 19. Would you rather have your baby be able to draw scribbles at 11 months but not understand cause and effect, or understand cause and effect at 18 months but only draw random lines? 20. Would you rather have your baby be a natural at pretend play from 12 months but have little interest in puzzles, or be a puzzle master but not engage in imaginative play? Becoming a new mom is an incredible, transformative experience, filled with moments of pure joy and, let's be honest, moments that make you question everything! Would You Rather Questions For New Moms offer a lighthearted escape, a chance to connect with other moms over the shared (and often hilarious) realities of this new chapter. So next time you're in the thick of it, grab a few of these questions and share a laugh – you're not alone in this beautiful, messy adventure.

Related Articles: