73 Would You Rather Questions For Music Class

Let's face it, sometimes music class can feel a little dry. We learn about notes, rhythms, and instruments, but what if we could inject a little fun and critical thinking into the mix? That's where Would You Rather Questions For Music Class come in! These imaginative scenarios are a fantastic way to get students talking, debating, and really thinking about music in a new light.

What Are Would You Rather Questions For Music Class?

So, what exactly are Would You Rather Questions For Music Class? Simply put, they're like mini thought experiments designed to make you choose between two equally interesting, challenging, or even hilarious musical situations. Instead of just reading about a concept, you're forced to imagine yourself in a specific scenario and make a decision. This interactive approach can be incredibly effective because it taps into our natural curiosity and desire to engage with interesting dilemmas. They're popular because they're low-stakes but high-reward for sparking conversation and revealing different perspectives. For instance, a question might ask if you'd rather be able to play any instrument perfectly but never sing, or have a beautiful singing voice but only be able to play the triangle. See? It’s not always an easy choice!

The beauty of these questions lies in their versatility. Teachers can use them in a variety of ways to enhance the learning experience:

• To kick off a lesson and gauge prior knowledge or spark interest.
• As a quick warm-up activity to get brains thinking musically.
• To encourage class discussions and collaborative problem-solving.
• As a way to explore musical concepts like genre, performance, creativity, and appreciation in a more engaging format.

When students are presented with these choices, they have to justify their reasoning, which is where the real learning happens. They might need to consider:

1. The practical implications of their choice.
2. The emotional impact of each option.
3. The technical aspects of music involved.
4. How their choice aligns with their personal musical preferences.

This process encourages students to articulate their thoughts clearly and respectfully, while also learning to consider viewpoints different from their own.

Would You Rather Questions For Music Class: Instrument Dilemmas

• Would you rather be able to play the guitar like Jimi Hendrix but only be able to play one song, or be able to play the kazoo perfectly for any song but never get better?
• Would you rather have a Stradivarius violin that only plays out of tune, or a rusty tin whistle that plays every note perfectly?
• Would you rather have fingers that automatically play the piano beautifully but have no feeling, or have hands that can feel every nuance of every instrument but can't physically play a note?
• Would you rather be able to shred on electric guitar at lightning speed but only in front of an empty room, or be able to play the ukulele flawlessly but only for an audience of one very unimpressed pigeon?
• Would you rather have an endless supply of perfect drumsticks that never break but they always smell faintly of cheese, or have a drum kit that looks amazing but makes a sound like a dying duck?
• Would you rather be able to perfectly mimic any brass instrument's sound with your voice but have terrible stage fright, or be able to play the trumpet with unmatched skill but have stage presence of a plank of wood?
• Would you rather have an orchestra of squirrels who only play polka music, or a single, very enthusiastic goat who plays incredibly complex jazz solos?
• Would you rather be able to instantly master any string instrument but never be able to read music, or be able to read complex orchestral scores but only be able to play the triangle?
• Would you rather have your piano play the wrong note every time you think about homework, or have your guitar strings spontaneously combust if you play a song you don't like?
• Would you rather be able to conjure up any percussion instrument out of thin air but they only make fart noises, or have a magical metronome that always sets the tempo to agonizingly slow?
• Would you rather your accordion only play sea shanties, even if you're trying to play a pop song, or your harmonica only play funeral dirges?
• Would you rather have a harp that plays itself beautiful melodies but only when you're sleeping, or a lute that you can play perfectly but it only sounds good when you're upside down?
• Would you rather be able to play the saxophone backwards with your feet, or be able to conduct a choir of very confused cats?
• Would you rather have your drum solos always sound like a stampede of rhinos, or your cymbals always crash at the most inappropriate moments?
• Would you rather your synthesizer could produce any sound imaginable but it only responds to interpretive dance, or your bass guitar could play the grooviest basslines but only if you're wearing a clown nose?
• Would you rather have a cello that cries whenever you play a sad song, or a banjo that giggles when you play a happy one?
• Would you rather be able to play the mandolin with virtuosic talent but only when you're underwater, or be able to play the bagpipes but they only sound good when you're juggling?
• Would you rather have a keyboard that can play any melody but it randomly adds a "boing" sound effect after each note, or a microphone that amplifies your voice but makes you sound like a chipmunk?
• Would you rather have a drum machine that creates the most intricate rhythms but it only speaks in riddles, or a pair of maracas that always shake in perfect time but they also emit a faint smell of garlic?
• Would you rather be able to play every instrument in a marching band simultaneously with your mind, but you can only march in circles, or be able to play the tuba so well it makes flowers bloom, but you can only play it while standing on one leg?

Would You Rather Questions For Music Class: Vocal Vocab

• Would you rather have a voice that can hit any note perfectly but sounds like a frog croaking, or have a voice that sounds like an angel but can only sing off-key?
• Would you rather be able to harmonize with any song effortlessly but your speaking voice is a whisper, or have a booming speaking voice but can only sing in a monotone?
• Would you rather your voice be so loud it shatters glass whenever you sing, or so quiet you can only be heard by people with super-hearing?
• Would you rather be able to scat like Ella Fitzgerald but only when you're asleep, or be able to belt like Adele but only when you're underwater?
• Would you rather have a voice that can mimic any sound in the world but you can't control it, or have a voice that's always perfectly in tune but you can only sing children's songs?
• Would you rather your singing always sound like it’s being played backward, or your rapping always sound like it’s being played at double speed?
• Would you rather be able to sing opera with incredible power but only in the shower, or be able to whisper-sing any song in a stadium and have it be heard by everyone?
• Would you rather your vocal cords only produce sound when you're thinking about food, or your voice permanently sound like you have a head cold?
• Would you rather be able to sing in perfect autotune without trying, but you can only sing love songs, or be able to sing any genre but your voice cracks on every high note?
• Would you rather your singing voice always be accompanied by a faint kazoo sound, or your rapping voice always be accompanied by a faint chicken clucking sound?
• Would you rather have a voice that can make people cry with emotion but you can't control when it happens, or a voice that makes people laugh uncontrollably whenever you sing?
• Would you rather be able to sing a lullaby so soothing it puts entire cities to sleep, or sing a battle cry so inspiring it rallies armies, but you can only do the opposite of what's needed?
• Would you rather your voice be able to perfectly replicate any animal sound but you can't sing human songs, or be able to sing any human song but you can only do it with animal noises?
• Would you rather have your singing voice be perfectly in tune but it always sounds like you're being tickled, or your singing voice be slightly off-key but it sounds incredibly passionate?
• Would you rather be able to sing a harmony with yourself in real-time but you can only sing in Klingon, or be able to sing a duet with any famous singer from history but they only sing in the wrong key?
• Would you rather your voice be able to project across vast distances but it always sounds like you're shouting, or your voice be able to whisper perfectly but only directly into someone's ear?
• Would you rather be able to sing a song that instantly makes everyone happy but it’s always the same song, or be able to sing a song that perfectly captures any emotion but you can only sing it once?
• Would you rather your voice always sound like it's being filtered through a tin can, or your voice always sound like it's being recorded on a cheap microphone?
• Would you rather be able to sing any song in any language but you forget the lyrics halfway through, or be able to sing one song perfectly in one language but you can only sing it once a year?
• Would you rather have a voice that can mimic perfect pitch but you can't remember melodies, or a voice that can remember melodies perfectly but you can't hit the notes?

Would You Rather Questions For Music Class: Musical Eras and Genres

• Would you rather live in the Baroque era and attend every Bach concert but have to wear a powdered wig every day, or live in the 1970s disco era and attend every Bee Gees concert but have to wear bell-bottoms and platform shoes?
• Would you rather be a punk rock rebel in the 1970s with no money but all the attitude, or a classical composer in the 1700s with wealth but strict social rules?
• Would you rather be able to only listen to Gregorian Chants for the rest of your life, or only listen to death metal for the rest of your life?
• Would you rather be able to time travel to any Mozart concert but have to sit in the nosebleed section, or be able to attend any Woodstock festival but have to camp in the rain?
• Would you rather be fluent in every ancient musical instrument but only be able to listen to music from the 1980s, or be able to listen to any music from any era but only be able to play the spoons?
• Would you rather be able to compose symphonies like Beethoven but only have them performed by a one-man band, or be a one-hit wonder pop star who makes millions but never writes another song?
• Would you rather be stuck on a desert island with only opera music, or stuck on a desert island with only country music?
• Would you rather be able to dance like John Travolta in Saturday Night Fever but only to polka music, or be able to play the electric guitar like a rock god but only for an audience of statues?
• Would you rather be able to attend a secret jam session with jazz legends but you can't speak, or be able to meet your favorite hip-hop artist but you can only communicate through interpretive dance?
• Would you rather invent a new genre of music that sounds like alien whale songs but it becomes globally popular, or be a world-renowned performer of an existing genre but only perform to your pet goldfish?
• Would you rather be able to predict the next big music trend but have no talent yourself, or have immense musical talent but never be able to predict trends?
• Would you rather have your life soundtracked by only happy-go-lucky ukulele music, or only dramatic film scores?
• Would you rather be able to lead a massive choir through a powerful oratorio but you can't sing a note yourself, or be able to sing a solo that moves an audience to tears but you can't conduct a single person?
• Would you rather be able to perfectly recreate any Beatles song but only using kitchen utensils, or be able to play any heavy metal riff but you have to do it while riding a unicycle?
• Would you rather be able to perfectly dance the tango but only to a lullaby, or be able to perfectly sing a rap but only in ancient Greek?
• Would you rather be stuck in a time loop of only the 1950s sock hop, or a time loop of only avant-garde performance art?
• Would you rather discover a lost symphony by a forgotten composer that sounds amazing but no one believes you, or have a band that plays your original music but they sound terrible?
• Would you rather have your music taste be stuck in one decade forever (your choice), or have your music taste randomly change every hour?
• Would you rather be able to attend any music festival in the world but you have to wear a full-body chicken costume, or be able to have a private concert from your favorite artist but they only play polka?
• Would you rather have your entire musical knowledge erased but be able to instantly learn any new instrument, or retain all your musical knowledge but never be able to learn a new instrument?

Would You Rather Questions For Music Class: Performance Predicaments

• Would you rather forget all the lyrics to your song mid-performance in front of thousands, or have your instrument break halfway through your solo?
• Would you rather have your microphone feedback loudly throughout your entire performance, or have the spotlight consistently shine directly in your eyes?
• Would you rather your bandmates all forget their parts at the same time during a crucial moment, or have a technical malfunction that cuts off all your sound?
• Would you rather be able to play any instrument perfectly but have stage fright so severe you can't move, or have amazing stage presence but only be able to play one note?
• Would you rather have your costume fall apart on stage, or have your music sheet blow away in the wind?
• Would you rather be able to improvise flawlessly but have no idea what you're going to play, or be able to play perfectly rehearsed pieces but have no ability to improvise?
• Would you rather have your audience all be incredibly polite but completely unresponsive, or have a rowdy audience that talks and heckles throughout your performance?
• Would you rather your performance be critically acclaimed but you receive no payment, or be paid handsomely but receive terrible reviews?
• Would you rather have your opening act be so bad it ruins the mood for everyone, or have your closing act be so good it overshadows your entire performance?
• Would you rather be able to play any song from memory but you can't read music, or be able to read any complex score but you can only play one song?
• Would you rather have your performance go viral for all the wrong reasons (e.g., a hilarious mishap), or have it be completely ignored?
• Would you rather be able to command an entire orchestra with just your gestures but you can't hear them, or be able to hear every nuance of every instrument but you can't conduct?
• Would you rather your only audience be a group of very critical judges who rate everything you do, or an audience of very enthusiastic babies who just gurgle and clap?
• Would you rather have your instrument accidentally hit a judge during your performance, or have your voice crack on the highest note of the climax?
• Would you rather be able to play the most complex piece of music perfectly but only when you're completely alone, or be able to play simple songs flawlessly in front of a massive crowd?
• Would you rather have your performance be broadcast live to millions but you're completely unaware, or have a small, intimate performance where you know everyone is watching your every move?
• Would you rather your band's logo be incredibly embarrassing but your music is amazing, or your band's logo be cool but your music is mediocre?
• Would you rather be able to control the lighting and special effects for your performance but not play any music, or play amazing music but have the lighting be consistently dim and boring?
• Would you rather have your instrument randomly start playing itself at the wrong time during your performance, or have your microphone suddenly start broadcasting your private thoughts?
• Would you rather be able to mesmerize an audience with your performance but they forget it the moment it ends, or have a forgettable performance that leaves a lasting emotional impact?

Would You Rather Questions For Music Class: Music Creation Conundrums

• Would you rather be able to write incredibly catchy melodies but have terrible lyrics, or write brilliant lyrics but have boring melodies?
• Would you rather have your music be incredibly popular but you hate it, or have your music be something you love but no one listens to?
• Would you rather be able to produce a hit song with any instrument but you can only use a triangle, or be able to use any instrument but only for background noise?
• Would you rather invent a completely new instrument that sounds amazing but is impossible to play, or invent a terrible-sounding instrument that is incredibly easy to play?
• Would you rather have your music inspire millions but you can never take credit, or have your music be plagiarized by someone else who becomes famous?
• Would you rather be able to remix any song perfectly but only into polka, or be able to create original music but it always sounds like elevator music?
• Would you rather your songwriting process involve randomly throwing darts at a word list for lyrics, or have to write lyrics based on the weather report?
• Would you rather be able to create amazing sound effects for movies but you can't make music, or create beautiful music but you can only use sound effects?
• Would you rather your music be considered "too ahead of its time" and never understood, or "outdated" and never discovered?
• Would you rather have a songwriting partner who is a genius but incredibly annoying, or a partner who is pleasant but has no creative ideas?
• Would you rather your music be perfect but unreleased, or released but flawed?
• Would you rather be able to compose a symphony in your head but have no way to write it down, or be able to write down any music but have no musical talent?
• Would you rather your music be incredibly complex and technical but emotionless, or simple and emotional but technically lacking?
• Would you rather have a perfect recording studio but only be able to record one note, or a terrible recording setup but be able to record full songs?
• Would you rather invent a new music production technique that becomes famous but you get no recognition, or have your song become a hit but be completely forgotten?
• Would you rather be able to create music that manipulates emotions but you can't feel them yourself, or feel emotions deeply but can't translate them into music?
• Would you rather your music be used in commercials for products you dislike, or your music be used in propaganda?
• Would you rather have a song go viral for an accidental sound effect, or have your carefully crafted masterpiece be ignored?
• Would you rather be able to create music that makes people dance uncontrollably but it's always the same dance, or create music that evokes deep thought but it’s always melancholic?
• Would you rather have your musical ideas come to you in dreams but you forget them upon waking, or have musical ideas come to you only when you're completely stressed out?

Would You Rather Questions For Music Class: Musical Etiquette and Appreciation

• Would you rather have to clap after every single note you hear, or never be able to clap again?
• Would you rather only be able to listen to music through tinny earbuds that barely work, or only be able to listen to music through massive, clunky headphones that make you look ridiculous?
• Would you rather have to hum along to every piece of music you hear, whether you want to or not, or have to tap your foot incessantly to any rhythm?
• Would you rather be able to perfectly identify any composer but never remember song titles, or be able to remember every song title but never identify a composer?
• Would you rather have to review every song you hear with overly dramatic and nonsensical adjectives, or have to rate every song on a scale of 1 to 10 but can only use prime numbers?
• Would you rather be forced to only listen to music on cassette tapes, or only listen to music through a dial-up internet connection?
• Would you rather have to dance enthusiastically to any music played, even if you hate it, or have to pretend to be deeply moved by any music, even if you find it boring?
• Would you rather be able to hear the "inner thoughts" of musicians while they play but not their music, or hear the music perfectly but have no idea what the musicians are thinking?
• Would you rather have to critique every song you hear by comparing it to a specific type of food, or by comparing it to a specific type of weather?
• Would you rather have your playlist always be the same five songs on repeat for a year, or have your playlist constantly be shuffled with random songs from every genre imaginable?
• Would you rather have to attend a concert where everyone is silent and just stares at the stage, or a concert where everyone is loudly singing along to every single song, including instrumentals?
• Would you rather be able to perfectly recall any musical performance you’ve ever seen but forget who the artists were, or remember all the artists but forget how they performed?
• Would you rather have to wear a t-shirt with the lyrics of the song you're listening to emblazoned on it, or have to publicly announce the tempo of every song you hear?
• Would you rather be able to understand the technical theory behind every piece of music but not enjoy it, or enjoy all music but have no understanding of its construction?
• Would you rather have to start every conversation with a musical quote, or end every conversation with a musical sound effect?
• Would you rather be able to identify the key of any song instantly but always be slightly out of tune yourself, or be able to sing perfectly in tune but never know the key?
• Would you rather have to listen to music at a volume that is either deafening or inaudibly quiet, with no in-between, or have to listen to music that is always slightly distorted?
• Would you rather be able to appreciate the artistry of every single instrument equally, or have an overwhelming favoritism for one specific instrument to the exclusion of all others?
• Would you rather have to judge a music competition where all the contestants are fantastic but they all play the same song, or where all the contestants are terrible but they all play completely different genres?
• Would you rather be able to predict the exact moment a song will end but not enjoy the journey, or get lost in the music and have no idea when it will finish?

So, there you have it! Would You Rather Questions For Music Class are more than just a game; they’re a gateway to deeper musical understanding and a whole lot of fun. Whether you're exploring instruments, vocal techniques, musical eras, performance challenges, creative processes, or even just how we appreciate music, these questions can transform a regular class into an engaging and memorable experience. They encourage students to think critically, express their opinions, and connect with music on a personal level, making learning an adventure rather than a chore.