73 School Would You Rather Questions

School can be a place of learning, friendship, and sometimes, tough choices. That's where School Would You Rather Questions come in! These fun prompts are designed to get you thinking, laughing, and maybe even debating with your friends. They present you with two tricky scenarios, forcing you to pick the lesser of two "evils" or the more appealing of two awesome, but impossible, options. Let's dive into the world of School Would You Rather Questions and see what kind of fun dilemmas we can uncover!

What Are School Would You Rather Questions?

School Would You Rather Questions are basically brain teasers presented as a choice between two things related to school life. They're not about finding the "right" answer, but about exploring your preferences, your priorities, and sometimes, your sense of humor. Think of them as mini-dilemmas that make you pause and consider what you'd truly prefer. They're super popular because they're easy to understand, fun to discuss, and can reveal a lot about what people think and feel, even in silly situations.

These questions are used in all sorts of ways. You might hear them:

At lunch with friends.
As a way to break the ice in a new group.
During a classroom activity to encourage discussion.
To spark creativity for writing prompts.

The importance of these questions lies in their ability to encourage critical thinking and communication. They get you to articulate why you made a certain choice, which is a valuable skill. It's like a low-stakes practice for making decisions and explaining your reasoning. Plus, they're just plain fun and can lead to some hilarious conversations about what we like and dislike about our school experiences.

Classroom Dilemmas

Would you rather have to sing everything you say in class or dance everywhere you walk in class?
Would you rather always have the answer but be unable to speak it, or always know how to ask the right question but never know the answer?
Would you rather have your teacher only ever give you pop quizzes, or only ever give you assignments that are worth 90% of your grade?
Would you rather have every essay you write be graded on a curve where the highest grade is a C, or have every test be graded out of 10 points?
Would you rather have to do all your homework in a library that's always silent, or in a cafeteria that's always noisy?
Would you rather have a mandatory nap time during every class or a mandatory snack time during every class?
Would you rather have to wear a silly hat every day or have to wear mismatched socks every day?
Would you rather have a principal who is incredibly strict but fair, or incredibly lenient but unfair?
Would you rather have to give a presentation every week to the whole school or write a research paper every month on a topic you hate?
Would you rather have a substitute teacher who is really boring and teaches the lesson perfectly, or a substitute teacher who is really fun but barely teaches anything?
Would you rather have all your homework be graded on your handwriting or on your spelling?
Would you rather have to stay after school for detention every time you're 1 minute late, or every time you talk in class?
Would you rather have your desk always be sticky or have your chair always be wobbly?
Would you rather have to read every book out loud to the class or have to write a summary of every book after reading it?
Would you rather have your teacher assign you extra homework for good behavior or less homework for bad behavior?
Would you rather have to answer every question with a rhyme or answer every question with a song?
Would you rather have your locker stuck open all the time or stuck shut all the time?
Would you rather have to bring in a healthy snack for the whole class every Friday or a fun craft supply for the whole class every Friday?
Would you rather have to always be the note-taker for the class or always be the one to answer the teacher's questions?
Would you rather have to wear your P.E. uniform all day every day or have to wear a formal suit every day?

Friendship Quandaries

Would you rather have a best friend who is always super loud or always super quiet?
Would you rather have a friend who always tells you what you want to hear, or a friend who always tells you the honest truth, even if it hurts?
Would you rather have a friend who borrows your stuff and never returns it, or a friend who borrows your stuff and breaks it?
Would you rather have a friend who is always late or a friend who is always early?
Would you rather have a friend who copies your style or a friend who is always trying to outdo you?
Would you rather have a friend who constantly interrupts you or a friend who never says anything?
Would you rather have a friend who always wants to do what you want to do, or a friend who always wants to do something different?
Would you rather have a friend who is great at making you laugh but terrible at giving advice, or terrible at making you laugh but great at giving advice?
Would you rather have a friend who is always borrowing money and never pays you back, or a friend who is always borrowing your clothes and stretching them out?
Would you rather have a friend who is always trying to set you up on dates or a friend who is always trying to set you up for pranks?
Would you rather have a friend who is incredibly popular but you barely see them, or a friend who is not very popular but you see them all the time?
Would you rather have a friend who agrees with everything you say or a friend who always challenges your ideas?
Would you rather have a friend who you can never tell secrets to, or a friend who tells all your secrets?
Would you rather have a friend who is always gossiping about others or a friend who is always gossiping about you?
Would you rather have a friend who is incredibly funny but annoying, or incredibly boring but very helpful?
Would you rather have to share your lunch with a friend every day or share your backpack with a friend every day?
Would you rather have a friend who constantly asks for favors or a friend who constantly needs your help?
Would you rather have a friend who always tries to make you the center of attention or a friend who always tries to make you blend in?
Would you rather have a friend who is very clumsy or a friend who is very clumsy?
Would you rather have a friend who is always bragging about their achievements or a friend who is always complaining about their problems?

Extracurricular Activities

Would you rather be the star player on a losing sports team or a benchwarmer on a winning sports team?
Would you rather be in the school play but have a tiny role, or be in the school band but play an instrument you dislike?
Would you rather have to join the chess club and actually become good, or join the drama club and have to perform a solo?
Would you rather be the president of the student council and have to deal with all the problems, or be the captain of the debate team and have to win every argument?
Would you rather have to be in the marching band and wear a hot uniform in the summer, or have to be in the swim team and wear a cold swimsuit in the winter?
Would you rather have to be in the photography club and always have to take unflattering pictures, or be in the art club and have to paint things you don't like?
Would you rather be the editor of the school newspaper and have to write about boring topics, or be the lead anchor for the school news broadcast and have to read a teleprompter with errors?
Would you rather have to participate in a science fair where your project always fails spectacularly, or a spelling bee where you always misspell the easiest words?
Would you rather be in the choir and have to sing in a language you don't understand, or be in the orchestra and have to play a solo you can't master?
Would you rather have to be the mascot for the school and be incredibly hot and sweaty, or have to be the referee for every game and make unpopular calls?
Would you rather be in the robotics club and have to build things that never work, or be in the coding club and have to fix bugs that are impossible to find?
Would you rather have to be the organizer for all school events and deal with budget cuts, or have to be the performer at all school events and deal with stage fright?
Would you rather be in the yearbook committee and have to take awkward photos of people, or be in the yearbook committee and have to write captions that make no sense?
Would you rather have to join the cooking club and make dishes that taste terrible, or join the gardening club and have to deal with all the bugs?
Would you rather be the president of the book club and have to read books you hate, or be the secretary of the book club and have to take notes on books you don't understand?
Would you rather have to be in the film club and have to star in a movie where you look silly, or be in the film club and have to edit a movie that's boring?
Would you rather be in the debate club and always have to argue for the wrong side, or be in the mock trial club and always have to play the guilty party?
Would you rather have to be in the peer tutoring program and help students who don't want to learn, or be in the peer mediation program and have to break up fights?
Would you rather be in the environmental club and have to clean up gross places, or be in the animal shelter club and have to deal with smelly animals?
Would you rather have to be the student representative for school dances and plan everything, or have to be the DJ for school dances and play songs nobody likes?

School Supplies and Gadgets

Would you rather have a backpack that always weighs 100 pounds or a pencil case that always runs out of pencils?
Would you rather have a calculator that only does addition or a ruler that only measures in inches?
Would you rather have a notebook that only has blank pages or a notebook that is already filled with someone else's messy notes?
Would you rather have a pen that always leaks ink or a glue stick that never sticks anything?
Would you rather have a stapler that always jams or a hole punch that only punches one hole at a time?
Would you rather have a whiteboard that is always smudged or a projector that is always flickering?
Would you rather have a computer that only works when it's unplugged or a printer that only prints in black and white?
Would you rather have a lunchbox that keeps your food cold but never warm, or warm but never cold?
Would you rather have a pair of scissors that are always dull or a sharpener that never sharpens?
Would you rather have a set of crayons where all the colors look the same or a set of markers that all smell like rotten eggs?
Would you rather have a binder that always falls apart or a folder that is too small for your papers?
Would you rather have a phone charger that only works when you hold it at a specific angle or headphones that only play one earbud?
Would you rather have a desk that is always too high or always too low?
Would you rather have a pair of glasses that make everything blurry or a pair of glasses that make everything look like a funny cartoon?
Would you rather have a water bottle that always leaks or a pencil case that always opens up and spills?
Would you rather have a calculator that only has the number 7 or a calculator that only has the number 0?
Would you rather have a book that is constantly falling apart or a book with missing pages?
Would you rather have a backpack that is incredibly heavy but stylish or incredibly light but unfashionable?
Would you rather have a pencil that is always too short to hold or a pen that constantly runs out of ink?
Would you rather have a locker that is too small for anything you own or a locker that is too big and everything gets lost inside?

School Food and Lunch Breaks

Would you rather eat cafeteria food for every meal or bring your own packed lunch every day but it always gets ruined?
Would you rather have the worst food in the cafeteria every single day, or have the best food but only once a month?
Would you rather have your lunch break be only 5 minutes long or have your lunch break be 2 hours long but you have to spend it doing chores?
Would you rather have to eat the same mystery meat every day for lunch or have to eat a salad with only one piece of lettuce and dressing?
Would you rather have your lunch table always be full of loud talkers or always be full of people who don't talk at all?
Would you rather have to share your entire lunch with one person every day or have to share your entire lunch with the whole class every day?
Would you rather have your lunch be incredibly delicious but you can only eat it with your hands, or incredibly bland but you can use utensils?
Would you rather have to eat dessert before your main course every day or eat your main course before your dessert every day?
Would you rather have a lunch break where you can only talk about homework or a lunch break where you can only talk about your favorite TV shows?
Would you rather have your lunch delivered to you at your desk every day or have to go to a special food court that's a mile away?
Would you rather have your lunch be so hot it burns your tongue or so cold it makes your teeth ache?
Would you rather have to eat your lunch in complete silence or eat your lunch while someone sings opera to you?
Would you rather have the cafeteria serve only vegetables or only candy?
Would you rather have your lunch break interrupted by a pop quiz every day or by a mandatory dance party every day?
Would you rather have your lunch always be the same color or always be the same shape?
Would you rather have to eat your lunch with a giant spoon or a tiny spoon?
Would you rather have to swap lunches with a random person every day or swap lunches with your teacher every day?
Would you rather have your lunch be incredibly healthy but taste awful or incredibly unhealthy but taste amazing?
Would you rather have to eat your lunch in the waiting room of the principal's office or in the janitor's closet?
Would you rather have your lunch break be at 7 AM or 10 PM?

School Rules and Consequences

Would you rather have to wear a uniform that is incredibly itchy or a uniform that is incredibly baggy?
Would you rather have a strict no-talking rule in the hallways or a strict no-walking rule in the hallways?
Would you rather get detention for being 1 minute late or for having messy handwriting?
Would you rather have to write "I will not talk in class" 100 times or do 50 jumping jacks every time you talk in class?
Would you rather have your phone confiscated for the entire school year or have to sing the school song every morning in front of everyone?
Would you rather have to wear a dunce cap for an hour if you get an answer wrong or have to stand in the corner for an hour?
Would you rather have a rule that says you can't laugh in school or a rule that says you can't smile in school?
Would you rather have to clean the entire school bathrooms every week or do all the custodial work for a month?
Would you rather have a consequence for talking too much or for not talking enough?
Would you rather have to write a 10-page essay on why you broke a rule or have to give a public apology to the entire school?
Would you rather have to wear a sign that says "I am a rule breaker" for a day or have to do an embarrassing dance in the middle of the cafeteria?
Would you rather have a rule that you can only speak in questions or a rule that you can only speak in answers?
Would you rather have to stay after school to write thank-you notes to everyone you've ever bothered or have to apologize to everyone you've ever annoyed?
Would you rather have a rule that you can't use any slang or a rule that you can't use any contractions?
Would you rather have to pick up all the litter on school grounds for a week or have to polish all the trophies in the trophy case?
Would you rather have a consequence for being too loud in the library or too quiet in the classroom?
Would you rather have to wear a ridiculous hat every day you are in trouble or have to wear a silly sticker every day?
Would you rather have a rule that you can only walk backwards in the hallways or only hop?
Would you rather have to write a 20-page report on the history of the school's rules or create a song about all the rules?
Would you rather have a rule that prohibits all forms of doodling or a rule that prohibits all forms of humming?

School Year and Holidays

Would you rather have a school year that is only 6 months long but has no breaks, or a school year that is 12 months long with constant holidays?
Would you rather have Christmas break be only one day long or have summer vacation be only one day long?
Would you rather have to attend school on every single holiday, or have school canceled every time it rains?
Would you rather have your birthday fall on the last day of school every year or the first day of school every year?
Would you rather have a summer vacation where it's always 100 degrees Fahrenheit or always 0 degrees Fahrenheit?
Would you rather have every single day of the school year feel like a Monday or every single day feel like a Friday?
Would you rather have to attend school during all the major holidays or have to attend school during all the major sporting events?
Would you rather have your school year start in July or end in July?
Would you rather have a week-long mid-winter break or a week-long mid-summer break?
Would you rather have to celebrate every single national holiday with a school-wide assembly or only celebrate your birthday with a school-wide assembly?
Would you rather have your school year end with final exams or start with final exams?
Would you rather have every day feel like the first day of school or the last day of school?
Would you rather have to celebrate Halloween in a blizzard or Thanksgiving in a heatwave?
Would you rather have a school year where every day is a surprise test or every day is a surprise party?
Would you rather have your spring break be in the dead of winter or your winter break be in the middle of summer?
Would you rather have to attend school on every single snow day or have to attend school on every single teacher work day?
Would you rather have your school year be entirely online or entirely in person with no technology?
Would you rather have a summer vacation where you have to do homework every day or a summer vacation where you have to go to summer school every day?
Would you rather have to celebrate every holiday by singing a song or by doing a dance?
Would you rather have your school year be incredibly short but incredibly difficult or incredibly long but incredibly easy?

So there you have it – a whole bunch of School Would You Rather Questions to get you and your friends talking! Whether you're pondering the best lunch break or the most inconvenient rule, these questions are a fantastic way to explore different perspectives and have a good laugh. They remind us that even in the everyday routine of school, there are always fun ways to think outside the box and engage with the world around us.