73 Biblical Would You Rather Questions

Ever found yourself in a lively discussion, maybe around a campfire or during a study group, and someone throws out a tricky "Would You Rather" question? Well, imagine taking those fun thought-starters and giving them a faith-filled twist! That's exactly what Biblical Would You Rather Questions are all about. They're a fantastic way to explore Bible stories, characters, and themes in a way that's not just informative, but also super engaging and thought-provoking.

What Are Biblical Would You Rather Questions and Why Are They So Cool?

Biblical Would You Rather Questions are playful yet profound scenarios that ask you to choose between two options, both rooted in biblical events, teachings, or characters. They're not about picking the "good" or "bad" choice in a simple way. Instead, they aim to make you think about the *why* behind certain actions, the motivations of people in the Bible, and the lessons we can learn from their experiences. They’re popular because they’re a fun way to get people talking about faith without it feeling like a lecture. You can use them in so many settings:

During youth group activities
As icebreakers for Bible studies
For family devotions
Even just for personal reflection

The goal isn't to get the "right" answer, but to spark conversation and deeper understanding. The importance of these questions lies in their ability to make us actively engage with scripture, considering different perspectives and applying timeless principles to relatable, albeit hypothetical, situations. They encourage us to think critically and compassionately:

Consider the character's feelings
Think about the consequences of their choices
Reflect on what God might have been teaching through the event

Would You Rather: Miracles and Divine Encounters

Would you rather have walked on water with Jesus or have been the one healed by his touch?
Would you rather have witnessed the parting of the Red Sea or seen the walls of Jericho fall?
Would you rather have been one of the disciples who saw Jesus transfigured or one who saw him after his resurrection?
Would you rather have been the boy who shared his loaves and fishes or the woman who poured perfume on Jesus' feet?
Would you rather have been present when Jesus calmed the storm or when he raised Lazarus from the dead?
Would you rather have been at the wedding in Cana, witnessing the first miracle, or at the feast of Pentecost, experiencing the Holy Spirit?
Would you rather have been a bystander at the feeding of the 5,000 or at the feeding of the 4,000?
Would you rather have seen the pillar of cloud by day and fire by night in the wilderness or witnessed the burning bush?
Would you rather have been one of the angels that appeared to the shepherds at Jesus' birth or one of the wise men who followed the star?
Would you rather have been part of the crowd that praised Jesus entering Jerusalem or part of the crowd that cried "Crucify him!"?
Would you rather have been healed by Jesus' spittle or have had your sins forgiven by him directly?
Would you rather have seen Moses strike the rock for water or Elijah call down fire from heaven?
Would you rather have been present when Jesus walked through locked doors after his resurrection or when he ascended into heaven?
Would you rather have been a prophet who saw visions of future events or an apostle who performed mighty signs?
Would you rather have been a leper who was cleansed by Jesus or a demon-possessed man who was delivered?
Would you rather have been part of the group that helped build Noah's ark or part of the group that escaped the flood?
Would you rather have received a message from an angel like Gideon or had a direct conversation with God like Moses?
Would you rather have witnessed Abraham being tested with Isaac or Job being tested with his possessions?
Would you rather have seen the pillar of fire that guided the Israelites or the cloud that overshadowed Mount Sinai?
Would you rather have been a witness to Peter's denial of Jesus or to Paul's conversion on the road to Damascus?

Would You Rather: Biblical Characters and Their Choices

Would you rather be a steadfast friend to Ruth or a loyal follower of Esther?
Would you rather have the faith of Abraham or the wisdom of Solomon?
Would you rather have the courage of David facing Goliath or the obedience of Jesus in Gethsemane?
Would you rather be known for your hospitality like the innkeeper in Bethlehem or your bravery like Rahab?
Would you rather have the passion of Paul for spreading the gospel or the compassion of Jesus for the suffering?
Would you rather be as diligent as Martha serving or as contemplative as Mary listening?
Would you rather have the perseverance of Joseph in slavery or the forgiveness of Joseph towards his brothers?
Would you rather have the boldness of Peter preaching or the gentle love of John?
Would you rather be as humble as Moses leading his people or as zealous as Elijah challenging false prophets?
Would you rather be known for your strength like Samson or your faithfulness like Daniel?
Would you rather have the artistic skill of Bezalel to build the tabernacle or the leadership of Joshua to conquer the Promised Land?
Would you rather be as patient as Job or as joyful as David dancing before the Ark?
Would you rather have the discernment of Deborah or the strength of Deborah in battle?
Would you rather have the humility of Stephen as he was stoned or the conviction of Paul as he faced persecution?
Would you rather be as proactive as Noah building the ark or as responsive as Mary saying "yes" to God?
Would you rather have the zeal of Philip sharing the gospel with the Ethiopian eunuch or the teaching ability of Apollos?
Would you rather be as obedient as Abraham in sacrificing Isaac or as trusting as the woman with the issue of blood?
Would you rather have the resilience of Paul through his trials or the unwavering faith of the Syrophoenician woman for her daughter?
Would you rather be as generous as Barnabas or as courageous as Peter walking on water?
Would you rather be as wise as Daniel interpreting dreams or as devoted as Mary Magdalene at the tomb?

Would You Rather: Temptations and Trials

Would you rather face temptation like Jesus in the desert for 40 days or face persecution like Paul in prison?
Would you rather be tested by doubt like Thomas or tested by fear like Peter when he denied Jesus?
Would you rather be tempted with power and riches like Jesus was or tempted with pride and self-reliance?
Would you rather face a famine like the one in Israel that sent the prodigal son away or a plague like the ones that struck Egypt?
Would you rather have your faith tested by suffering like Job or by misunderstanding like Jesus' own brothers?
Would you rather be tempted to compromise your beliefs for worldly gain or tempted to abandon your calling out of weariness?
Would you rather face the loneliness of exile like John on Patmos or the pressure of leadership like Moses on Mount Sinai?
Would you rather be tempted to envy the success of others or tempted to despair in your own failures?
Would you rather have your obedience challenged by a difficult command like Abraham's or your faithfulness challenged by betrayal like David's?
Would you rather be tempted with a quick fix that bypasses God's plan or tempted to give up when God's timing seems slow?
Would you rather face the shame of public failure like Peter after his denial or the isolation of persecution like Jeremiah?
Would you rather be tempted to follow the crowd's wrong path like the Israelites worshipping the golden calf or to stand alone in truth like Noah?
Would you rather have your patience tested by a long journey like the Israelites in the wilderness or by waiting for a promise like Sarah?
Would you rather be tempted to take matters into your own hands like Moses striking the rock in anger or to wait on God's provision?
Would you rather face the fear of overwhelming odds like Gideon's army or the fear of speaking truth to power like Nathan to David?
Would you rather be tempted to hoard blessings like Lot's wife looking back or to share them freely like the early church?
Would you rather have your courage tested by a dangerous mission like Jonah or by a dangerous conversation like Jesus with the Samaritan woman?
Would you rather be tempted to follow tradition even when it’s wrong like the Pharisees or to embrace new understanding like the disciples?
Would you rather face the temptation to doubt God's love during hardship like the Israelites in the desert or to trust in His faithfulness?
Would you rather have your commitment tested by hardship like Paul or by comfort like many in the church today?

Would You Rather: Everyday Life and Spiritual Disciplines

Would you rather have a daily quiet time filled with scripture reading or one focused on extended prayer?
Would you rather serve God through teaching or serve God through practical acts of kindness?
Would you rather be known for your fervent worship in a large group or your quiet devotion in private?
Would you rather have the gift of tongues for sharing the gospel or the gift of prophecy for encouraging the church?
Would you rather spend your time evangelizing lost souls or discipling new believers?
Would you rather have a strong sense of God's presence during worship services or during your daily work?
Would you rather lead a small group study or be a supportive member in one?
Would you rather be someone who always gives generously or someone who always prays faithfully for others?
Would you rather have the gift of encouragement or the gift of discernment in guiding others?
Would you rather focus your spiritual growth on understanding the Old Testament law or the New Testament grace?
Would you rather be someone who consistently forgives quickly or someone who is consistently patient through difficult situations?
Would you rather contribute to building a new church plant or to strengthening an established one?
Would you rather be a peacemaker in conflict situations or a voice of truth in challenging times?
Would you rather have the discipline of fasting for spiritual focus or the discipline of studying apologetics to defend your faith?
Would you rather be known for your joy in all circumstances or your steadfast hope in God?
Would you rather be someone who always seeks to understand others' perspectives or someone who always seeks to offer God's perspective?
Would you rather have a strong emphasis on social justice or personal holiness in your walk with God?
Would you rather be someone who consistently shares their faith with strangers or someone who builds deep spiritual friendships?
Would you rather have a talent for music in worship or a talent for hospitality in welcoming others?
Would you rather live a life of quiet obedience or a life of bold evangelism?

Would You Rather: The Kingdom of God and Our Role

Would you rather be a foundational stone in building God's kingdom or a bright light shining for it?
Would you rather have the wisdom to lead many or the humility to serve one?
Would you rather be known for your strong faith that moves mountains or your deep love that builds community?
Would you rather preach the gospel to a vast crowd or share it one-on-one with someone searching?
Would you rather help establish justice in a city or spread peace in a troubled home?
Would you rather be a mighty warrior for God's truth or a gentle gardener cultivating spiritual growth?
Would you rather have the ability to speak powerfully for God or the ability to listen deeply to His voice?
Would you rather be a voice of prophetic warning or a voice of comforting assurance in challenging times?
Would you rather contribute your skills to building a physical church building or to strengthening the spiritual church body?
Would you rather be recognized for your great deeds in God's kingdom or for your quiet, consistent faithfulness?
Would you rather be a shepherd guiding a flock or a sheepdog protecting it?
Would you rather focus on spreading the news of God's love to the ends of the earth or to your own neighborhood?
Would you rather be a courageous defender of the faith or a compassionate healer of brokenness?
Would you rather have the discernment to see God's plan unfolding or the strength to carry out your part in it?
Would you rather be known for your wisdom in decision-making or your radical obedience to God's commands?
Would you rather be a bridge builder between divided people or a lighthouse guiding lost souls to safety?
Would you rather have the faith to believe God for the impossible or the perseverance to endure through the difficult?
Would you rather be a messenger of God's judgment or a bearer of God's mercy?
Would you rather be a strong pillar supporting the church or a vibrant thread woven into its fabric?
Would you rather experience the awe of God's majesty or the intimacy of His presence?

Would You Rather: Future and Eternal Life

Would you rather be among the first to witness Jesus' second coming or among the first to enter the New Jerusalem?
Would you rather have an eternal reward of great authority in heaven or one of perfect peace and rest?
Would you rather be one of the elders around God's throne or one of the redeemed worshipping Him eternally?
Would you rather know the exact day of your earthly departure or the exact day of Jesus' return?
Would you rather be a participant in the wedding feast of the Lamb or a singer in the heavenly choir?
Would you rather have a clear understanding of all the mysteries of heaven or a perfect, unhindered communion with God?
Would you rather be part of ushering in the New Heavens and New Earth or simply enjoying their perfection?
Would you rather have the gift of seeing all your loved ones in heaven or the gift of knowing all the stories of the redeemed?
Would you rather be an angel announcing God's glory or a redeemed saint experiencing it firsthand?
Would you rather have the ability to revisit any moment of biblical history in heaven or to explore new creations eternally?
Would you rather be tasked with revealing God's justice or God's mercy to the universe in eternity?
Would you rather have your heavenly mansion be grand and magnificent or simple and intimately connected to God?
Would you rather be one of the builders of the New Jerusalem or one of its inhabitants?
Would you rather have the ability to understand all languages and cultures in eternity or the ability to create new forms of worship?
Would you rather be a guardian of the Tree of Life or a gardener in its eternal paradise?
Would you rather have a perfect understanding of God's will for all of creation or a perfect capacity to love and be loved?
Would you rather be a herald proclaiming God's victory or a witness to its unending celebration?
Would you rather have the reward of seeing God's face every day or the reward of serving Him constantly?
Would you rather be a participant in the judgment of evil or a recipient of perfect, eternal redemption?
Would you rather have an intimate knowledge of all the saints' stories or an infinite capacity for experiencing God's joy?

So, as you can see, Biblical Would You Rather Questions are a fantastic tool. They can transform the way we think about the Bible, making it come alive and encouraging us to connect with its timeless messages on a deeper level. Whether you’re looking for a fun way to learn or a thought-provoking discussion starter, these questions are sure to spark some engaging conversations and reveal new insights into the greatest story ever told.